5 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8BD
About 5 Castle Garden Street
5 Castle Garden Street is a semi-detached house in Penistone, Sheffield, Sheffield (S36 8BD). It has a recorded floor area of 75 m² (around 807 sq ft) and construction records dating it to 2021. The latest certificate (September 2023) returns a B (score 84), comfortably above the UK average. The recommended improvements would push it to A (score 96).
Across 2023–2024, sale prices on this property compounded at -57.1% per year. Today's modelled estimate of £174,000 sits 148.6% above the 2024 sale of £69,998. On a £-per-square-foot basis, the last sale (£87/sq ft) was about 74.5% below the postcode norm. Sold June 2024 for £69,998.
Energy performance
5 Castle Garden Street's carbon output is low for the local stock.
EPC Rating
Get a survey for this property
Level 2 HomeBuyer Report
We've checked 10 risk factors against the available data for this property and believe a Level 2 HomeBuyer Report could be a suitable option for you.
From £495 · Includes VAT
Planning history
5 Castle Garden Street has no planning applications on record.
But the area is active
1 notable application nearby — larger schemes and conversions that could reshape the street. The report maps them all.
Sales history & valuation
Latest sale on 5 Castle Garden Street was the lowest on Land Registry record across the postcode.
£174,000
Modelled from EPC, postcode comparables and a sale-price growth of -57.1% per year over 1 year.
£69,998
Growth on file: -57.1% per year over 1 year.
Sales timeline
6 June 2024Most recent
£69,998
-57.1%8 December 2023
£163,185
Median price across the last 5 sales in S36 8BD: £335,995 (2025–2024).
Nearby sales in S36 8BD
23 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8BD
Sold Jan 2025
£374,99519 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8BD
Sold Nov 2024
£263,11925 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8BD
Sold Aug 2024
£335,99521 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8BD
Sold Jun 2024
£335,99517 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8BD
Sold Jun 2024
£265,996
Versus other Castle Garden Street homes
Price per m² for 5 Castle Garden Street lags the street by a wide margin.
Price per m²
£933
Street avg £3,700
Floor Area
75 m²
Street avg 81 m²
CO₂ Emissions
1.3 t/year
Street avg 1.2 t/year
Years Held
2 years
Street avg 2 years
Similar properties nearby
1 Don View, Sheffield Road, Oxspring
S36 8YW
1 Haigh Cottages, Sheffield Road, Oxspring
S36 8YQ
1 Bank View, Sheffield Road, Oxspring
S36 8YQ
1 Near Coates Cottages, Coates Lane, Oxspring
S36 8YB
1 Mount Pleasant, Sheffield Road, Oxspring
S36 8YW
1 Bank View, Bower Hill Road, Oxspring
S36 8YA
1 Farmstead Drive, Penistone
S36 8BB
1 Far Coates Cottages, Coates Lane, Oxspring
S36 8YB
The neighbourhood at a glance
Crime
5/mo
Steady year-on-year across the wider district.
Nearest stop
0.2 km
Wellhouse Lane/Halifax Road — bus stop.
Closest school
0.5 km
Penistone Grammar School. 5 schools nearby.
Go deeper on the local area
A Local Area report breaks down crime, transport links, schools and air quality in depth.
Road noise across the postcode

Daytime· 07:00 – 23:00
50.9dB

Night-time· 23:00 – 07:00
42.9dB







