Nether Mill House, Barnsley Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8AD
About Nether Mill House
Nether Mill House is a two-bedroom detached house in Penistone, Sheffield, Sheffield (S36 8AD). It has a recorded floor area of 446 m² (around 4801 sq ft), construction records dating it to before 1900 and council tax band C. The latest certificate (October 2014) shows an F (score 26), near the bottom of the EPC scale. The recommended improvements would lift it to C (score 76), a 3-band jump. The latest certificate is from October 2014, so improvements made since then won't be reflected. Period features are noted in the property record. Our model identifies extension potential, subject to local planning policy.
At 446 m² the property is well over the postcode median (93 m² across 22 EPCs), placing it in the larger end of the local stock. On energy efficiency it sits in the bottom 10% of properties in this postcode — significant headroom for improvement. 3 planning records sit against the property, 3 approved, 0 refused. Past consents include an extension and a porch, meaningful when judging how the property has evolved. The record references listed-building consent, which constrain future alterations. On a £-per-square-foot basis, the last sale (£100/sq ft) was about 35% below the postcode norm. Last sale on file: £480,000 in December 2021. That sale was during the post-pandemic price surge, when transactions cleared materially above pre-2020 trend.
What this property has
Inside
- Bedrooms2
- Bathrooms1
- Dining roomYes
- FireplaceYes
Outside
- Private gardenYes
- ParkingOff road
Building
- Period featuresYes
- RefurbishedYes
- Extension potentialPossible
Energy performance
Nether Mill House sits at the bottom of the postcode for energy efficiency — meaningful headroom to improve.
EPC Expired
This certificate is over 10 years old and is no longer valid.Expired 22 Oct 2024
EPC Rating
Get a survey for this property
Level 3 Building Survey
Because the property was built before 1919, is a large detached home over 300m², and has been extended more than once, we believe a Level 3 building survey should be considered.
From £1,085 · Includes VAT
Planning history
Nether Mill House has multiple listed-building consents on file — alterations need formal heritage approval.
3 applications on record at Nether Mill House, Barnsley Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8AD
- Mar 2018PorchHeritageOutcome in report
Alterations to listed building to allow retention of some features and erection of porch (Listed Building Consent)
ListedExtension- Documents
- 15 docs on file
- Reference
- 2018/0127
- More recent applications — locked
- RenovationJul 2022Decision
- ConditionsApr 2018Decision
Unlock Nether Mill House, Barnsley Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8AD's full planning history
You're seeing the shape of it. The report has the substance.
- Every decision — granted, refused or withdrawn (3 on record)
- All 3 applications on this property in full, plus 1 notable nearby
- The 54 documents, officer reports & conditions
- What the pattern means for extending or converting here
One time fee only - money back guarantee
Sales history & valuation
Latest sale on Nether Mill House was the highest on Land Registry record across the postcode.
£514,000
Modelled from EPC, postcode comparables.
£480,000
Recorded with HM Land Registry.
Sales timeline
17 December 2021Most recent
£480,000
Median price across the last 5 sales in S36 8AD: £285,000 (2025–2024).
Nearby sales in S36 8AD
35 Barnsley Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8AD
Sold Jun 2025
£320,00041a, Barnsley Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8AD
Sold Dec 2024
£352,00023 Barnsley Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8AD
Sold Feb 2024
£180,00011 Barnsley Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8AD
Sold Feb 2024
£285,00014 Barnsley Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 8AD
Sold Dec 2022
£283,000
Versus other Barnsley Road homes
On floor area, Nether Mill House stands well clear of the street.
Price per m²
£1,076
Street avg £2,050
Floor Area
446 m²
Street avg 101 m²
Habitable Rooms
10 rooms
Street avg 5 rooms
CO₂ Emissions
37.0 t/year
Street avg 6.2 t/year
Similar properties nearby
1 Fox Fields, Oxspring
S36 8ZX
1 Old Manor Drive, Oxspring
S36 8ZY
1 Haigh Cottages, Sheffield Road, Oxspring
S36 8YQ
1 Don View, Sheffield Road, Oxspring
S36 8YW
1 East Road, Oxspring
S36 8YG
1 Mount Pleasant, Sheffield Road, Oxspring
S36 8YW
1 Near Coates Cottages, Coates Lane, Oxspring
S36 8YB
1 East Close, Oxspring
S36 8ZU
The neighbourhood at a glance
Rail-style transport is unusually close for this postcode.
Crime
5/mo
Steady year-on-year across the wider district.
Nearest stop
0.0 km
Barnsley Road/Wellhouse Lane — bus stop.
Closest school
0.5 km
Penistone Grammar School. 7 schools nearby.
Go deeper on the local area
A Local Area report breaks down crime, transport links, schools and air quality in depth.
Road noise across the postcode

Daytime· 07:00 – 23:00
51.2dB

Night-time· 23:00 – 07:00
42.7dB







