Fiddler Farm, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG
About Fiddler Farm
Fiddler Farm is a detached house in Thurgoland, Sheffield, Sheffield (S35 7EG). It has a recorded floor area of 132 m² (around 1421 sq ft), construction records dating it to before 1900 and council tax band F. The latest certificate (August 2018) shows an E (score 42), well below the UK norm with real room to improve. The recommended improvements would lift it to C (score 80), a 2-band jump.
Today's modelled estimate of £440,000 is 34.8% below the 2018 sale of £675,000, running counter to the wider postcode trend, which makes the EPC and condition history especially worth a look. On a £-per-square-foot basis, the last sale (£475/sq ft) was about 114.9% above the typical sold price in the postcode. At 132 m² it's 20% smaller than the typical home in the postcode (165 m² median across 33 EPCs). It lags the bulk of the postcode on energy efficiency (less efficient than 73% of similar EPCs). 3 planning records sit against the property, 3 approved, 0 refused. Most recent transfer: November 2018 at £675,000.
Know exactly what you're buying at Fiddler Farm
Before you offer, see what the listing won't tell you, the true value, the red flags and the full history.
Valuation
against the asking price
Risks
planning & flood
Sold prices
similar homes nearby
Trends
the local market
Energy performance
Fiddler Farm's carbon output runs well above what efficient homes in the postcode produce.
EPC Rating
Planning history
Fiddler Farm has an approved extension on the planning record.
- Jan 2022ExtensionFullIn report
Erection of extension to existing agricultural building
- Documents
- 5 docs on file
- Reference
- 2021/1595
- Apr 2019FullIn report
Erection of detached double garage and detached timber stable block to replace existing buildings.
- Documents
- 7 docs on file
- Reference
- 2019/0285
What's in Fiddler Farm, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG's planning history?
1 more on this property, plus refusals, disputes and full decisions nearby, in the report.
Sales history & valuation
Fiddler Farm valuation sits well clear of the typical sold price in this postcode.
£440,000
Modelled from EPC, postcode comparables.
£675,000
Recorded with HM Land Registry.
Sales timeline
30 November 2018Most recent
£675,000
Median price across the last 5 sales in S35 7EG: £475,000 (2025–2023).
Nearby sales in S35 7EG
Wantacyu, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG
Sold Feb 2025
£310,000Birch Croft, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG
Sold Feb 2025
£430,000Stonecroft, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG
Sold Oct 2024
£850,0001 Old Mill Cottages, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG
Sold Oct 2023
£475,00049 Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG
Sold Jun 2023
£630,000
Everything we know about Fiddler Farm, in one report
What it's really worth, what could be wrong, and the planning, sales and area data in full.
- Am I paying too much?
- Is something wrong with it?
- Is the agent's story true?
- Will it hold its value?

Versus other Old Mill Lane homes
On epc rating, Fiddler Farm runs well behind the street norm.
Price per m²
£5,114
Street avg £2,943
Floor Area
132 m²
Street avg 163 m²
Habitable Rooms
5 rooms
Street avg 7 rooms
CO₂ Emissions
10.0 t/year
Street avg 6.9 t/year
Similar properties nearby
1 Carlton Mews, Woodhead Road, Wortley
S35 7DA
1 Belmont Terrace, Thurgoland
S35 7AD
1 Chemistry Cottages, Forge Lane, Wortley
S35 7DN
1 Delph Edge, Green Moor, Wortley
S35 7DW
1 Castle View, Roper Lane, Thurgoland
S35 7AA
1 Carr Head Road, Howbrook, Wortley
S35 7HG
1 China Square, Crane Moor
S35 7AU
1 Delph Mews, Green Moor, Wortley
S35 7EQ
The neighbourhood at a glance
Daytime road noise here sits well below conversation level — a quiet pocket of the postcode.
Crime
2/mo
Steady year-on-year across the wider district.
Nearest stop
0.6 km
Cote Lane/Huthwaite Lane — bus stop.
Closest school
1.2 km
Thurgoland Church of England (Voluntary Controlled) Primary School. 8 schools nearby.
Go deeper on the local area
The full report breaks down crime, transport links, schools and air quality in depth.
Road noise across the postcode

Daytime· 07:00 – 23:00
43.1dB

Night-time· 23:00 – 07:00
36.0dB