2 Old Mill Cottages, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG
About 2 Old Mill Cottages
2 Old Mill Cottages is a semi-detached house in Thurgoland, Sheffield, Sheffield (S35 7EG). It has a recorded floor area of 155 m² (around 1668 sq ft) and council tax band E. The latest certificate (November 2018) shows a C (score 69), just inside the C band. The recommended improvements would lift it to A (score 92), a 2-band jump. Main heating runs on electricity: electricity, unspecified tariff.
Across 1998–2021, sale prices on this property compounded at 4.9% per year. Today's modelled estimate of £450,000 is 22.1% above the 2021 sale price. Last sale on file: £368,500 in May 2021. That sale was during the post-pandemic price surge, when transactions cleared materially above pre-2020 trend.
Know exactly what you're buying at 2 Old Mill Cottages
Before you offer, see what the listing won't tell you, the true value, the red flags and the full history.
Valuation
against the asking price
Risks
planning & flood
Sold prices
similar homes nearby
Trends
the local market
Energy performance
Recommended upgrades on file would lift this property by multiple EPC bands.
EPC Rating
Planning history
2 Old Mill Cottages has no planning applications on record.
The full report still covers planning activity across the surrounding area.
Sales history & valuation
2 Old Mill Cottages has more than tripled in price since its earliest registered sale in 1998.
£450,000
Modelled from EPC, postcode comparables and a sale-price growth of 4.9% per year over 23 years.
£368,500
Growth on file: 4.9% per year over 23 years.
Sales timeline
27 May 2021Most recent
£368,500
+207.1%over 23 years12 February 1998
£120,000
Median price across the last 5 sales in S35 7EG: £475,000 (2025–2023).
Nearby sales in S35 7EG
Wantacyu, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG
Sold Feb 2025
£310,000Birch Croft, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG
Sold Feb 2025
£430,000Stonecroft, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG
Sold Oct 2024
£850,0001 Old Mill Cottages, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG
Sold Oct 2023
£475,00049 Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG
Sold Jun 2023
£630,000
Everything we know about 2 Old Mill Cottages, in one report
What it's really worth, what could be wrong, and the planning, sales and area data in full.
- Am I paying too much?
- Is something wrong with it?
- Is the agent's story true?
- Will it hold its value?

Versus other Old Mill Lane homes
On co₂ emissions, 2 Old Mill Cottages stands well clear of the street.
Price per m²
£2,377
Street avg £3,087
Floor Area
155 m²
Street avg 162 m²
CO₂ Emissions
4.3 t/year
Street avg 7.1 t/year
Years Held
5 years
Street avg 9 years
Similar properties nearby
1 Carlton Mews, Woodhead Road, Wortley
S35 7DA
1 Belmont Terrace, Thurgoland
S35 7AD
1 Chemistry Cottages, Forge Lane, Wortley
S35 7DN
1 Castle View, Roper Lane, Thurgoland
S35 7AA
1 Delph Edge, Green Moor, Wortley
S35 7DW
1 Carr Head Road, Howbrook, Wortley
S35 7HG
1 China Square, Crane Moor
S35 7AU
1 Delph Mews, Green Moor, Wortley
S35 7EQ
The neighbourhood at a glance
Daytime road noise here sits well below conversation level — a quiet pocket of the postcode.
Crime
2/mo
Steady year-on-year across the wider district.
Nearest stop
0.6 km
Cote Lane/Huthwaite Lane — bus stop.
Closest school
1.2 km
Thurgoland Church of England (Voluntary Controlled) Primary School. 8 schools nearby.
Go deeper on the local area
The full report breaks down crime, transport links, schools and air quality in depth.
Road noise across the postcode

Daytime· 07:00 – 23:00
43.1dB

Night-time· 23:00 – 07:00
36.0dB