5 Nicholsons Cottages, Hinton St Mary, Sturminster Newton, DT10 1NF
About 5 Nicholsons Cottages
5 Nicholsons Cottages is a four-bedroom semi-detached house in Hinton St. Mary, Sturminster Newton, Sturminster Newton (DT10 1NF). It has a recorded floor area of 81 m² (around 874 sq ft), construction records dating it to 1930-1949 and council tax band C. The latest certificate (May 2009) shows an E (score 39), well below the UK norm with real room to improve. The recommended improvements would push it to D (score 57). Main heating runs on oil. The latest certificate is from May 2009, so improvements made since then won't be reflected. Records show the property has been extended at some point in its history.
Held since December 2009 — that's 16 years off the open market, well above the local norm. That sale fell during the post-crash dip, which often skews comparisons against later neighbouring sales. One planning record on file: an extension approved in 2002. Past consents include an extension, meaningful when judging how the property has evolved. Across 1999–2009, sale prices on this property compounded at 11.6% per year. Today's modelled estimate of £369,000 is 47.6% above the 2009 sale price. On a £-per-square-foot basis, the last sale (£286/sq ft) was about 19.1% above the typical sold price in the postcode.
Know exactly what you're buying at 5 Nicholsons Cottages
Before you offer, see what the listing won't tell you, the true value, the red flags and the full history.
Already flagged here
Valuation
against the asking price
Risks
planning & flood
Sold prices
similar homes nearby
Trends
the local market
What this property has
Inside
- Bedrooms4
- Dining roomYes
- EnsuiteYes
- StudyYes
Outside
- Private gardenWest-facing
- GarageYes
Building
- Previously extendedYes
Energy performance
5 Nicholsons Cottages's carbon output runs well above what efficient homes in the postcode produce.
EPC Expired
This certificate is over 10 years old and is no longer valid.Expired 27 May 2019
EPC Rating
Planning history
- Mar 2002ExtensionFullIn report
Extension: Two storey
Demolish existing store and erect two storey extension
- Council
- North Dorset
- Documents
- 4 docs on file
- Reference
- 2/2002/0112
We flagged 1 thing worth checking at 5 Nicholsons Cottages
Independent checks surfaced things a buyer would want to understand before offering. The report explains each one in full, with the underlying data and what to ask.
- Larger development activity nearby
30-day money-back guarantee
Sales history & valuation
Sale price has grown by over 3x since 1999.
£369,000
Modelled from EPC, postcode comparables and a sale-price growth of 11.6% per year over 10 years.
£249,950
Growth on file: 11.6% per year over 10 years.
Sales timeline
8 December 2009Most recent
£249,950
+212.4%over 10 years29 July 1999
£80,000
Median price across the last 5 sales in DT10 1NF: £295,000 (2025–2020).
Nearby sales in DT10 1NF
6 Nicholsons Cottages, Hinton St Mary, Sturminster Newton, DT10 1NF
Sold Jan 2025
£315,0002 Nicholsons Cottages, Hinton St Mary, Sturminster Newton, DT10 1NF
Sold Aug 2024
£300,0003 Nicholsons Cottages, Hinton St Mary, Sturminster Newton, DT10 1NF
Sold Apr 2023
£255,0009 Nicholsons Cottages, Hinton St Mary, Sturminster Newton, DT10 1NF
Sold Mar 2022
£295,0008 Nicholsons Cottages, Hinton St Mary, Sturminster Newton, DT10 1NF
Sold Aug 2010
£246,000
Everything we know about 5 Nicholsons Cottages, in one report
What it's really worth, what could be wrong, and the planning, sales and area data in full.
What we flagged
- Larger development activity nearby

Versus the street
5 Nicholsons Cottages outperforms the street on years held by a wide margin.
Price per m²
£3,079
Street avg £3,094
Floor Area
81 m²
Street avg 84 m²
Habitable Rooms
6 rooms
Street avg 4 rooms
CO₂ Emissions
11.0 t/year
Street avg 5.2 t/year
Similar properties nearby
1 Barnes Close
DT10 1BN
1 Badgers Way
DT10 1DA
1 Burges Close, Marnhull
DT10 1QQ
1 Chestnut Close, Marnhull
DT10 1FT
1 Barnes Close, Marnhull
DT10 1LL
1 Blackmore Vale Cottages, Burton Street, Marnhull
DT10 1JJ
1 Daltons Cottages, Hinton St Mary
DT10 1NA
1 Dashwood Close
DT10 1PF
The neighbourhood at a glance
Daytime road noise here sits well below conversation level — a quiet pocket of the postcode.
Crime
1/mo
Steady year-on-year across the wider district.
Nearest stop
0.2 km
Hinton Bus Shelter — bus stop.
Closest school
1.3 km
Sturminster Newton High School. 3 schools nearby.
Go deeper on the local area
The full report breaks down crime, transport links, schools and air quality in depth.
Road noise across the postcode

Daytime· 07:00 – 23:00
44.1dB

Night-time· 23:00 – 07:00
37.1dB